Skip to Main Content

Criminology

CRIM 2330 (Lyon)

This guide was created for students in Dave Lyon's CRIM 2330 class (Psychological Explanations of Criminal Behaviour) in Fall 2024.

Goal:

To learn how to search the PsycINFO database efficiently for relevant primary research articles and cite them in APA format.

What are scholarly or peer-reviewed journal articles?

What is a peer-reviewed journal?

PEER-REVIEWED JOURNALS are often called SCHOLARLY* or ACADEMIC* journals. They are different from popular magazines. Articles in peer-reviewed journals**:

  • are written by experts for other experts
  • usually report on research conducted or analyzed by the authors
  • always include many in-text citations and a list of references or works cited by the author(s)
  • most importantly have been rigorously critiqued and reviewed by experts for quality before being published. This is called peer-review.

*Notes:

*This is not strictly correct. A small minority of scholarly or academic journals do not use peer-review. Peer-reviewed journals are a large sub-set of academic/scholarly journals.
** Peer-reviewed journals often contain short articles such as letters to the editor, or book reviews which are NOT peer-reviewed. Database filters don't usually weed these out.

APA citation for video:
libncsu [North Carolina State University Libraries]. (2014). Peer review in 3 minutes [Video]. https://youtu.be/rOCQZ7QnoN0

Practice Question 1

Click on the link to each of the three items listed below. Each link opens in a new window. Look at all three items before voting.

To vote, click on the radio button for your choice, and click Submit. Please only vote once.

Which of these is an article from a peer-reviewed journal?

Item 1: Unlocking the nature of human aggression: A psychoanalytic and neuroscientific approach: 2 votes (3.85%)
Item 2: Patterns and correlates of offender versatility and specialization ...: 43 votes (82.69%)
Item 3: Brain chemical is reward for psychopathic traits: 1 votes (1.92%)
All of them: 4 votes (7.69%)
Not sure: 2 votes (3.85%)
Total Votes: 52

What are primary research articles?

Primary research articles

A primary source is the first publication of new research findings. 

  • written by the researchers themselves
  • usually published in peer-reviewed journals
  • often called PRIMARY or ORIGINAL research. They may also be called EMPIRICAL articles.

Secondary research articles

Secondary sources of information describe, explain, interpret or summarize primary sources.

  • These sources do NOT report on the authors' own research but discuss the original (previously-published) work of others.
  • These include encyclopedias, book reviews, commentaries, literature reviews, books, and other types of sources.
  • Many journal articles are secondary sources.
  • Although a secondary source can be very helpful for understanding a topic and identifying primary research articles, it is not a primary study itself.

screenshot of different types of material in scholarly journals


APA citation for this YouTube video:
Virginia Commonwealth University Libraries. (2011). Identifying scholarly article types [Video file]. https://youtu.be/uEsAKqXSfbY

Sections of an original research article include Abstract, Introduction, Method, Findings or Results, Discussion, Conclusion and References

Structure of a primary research article

A primary (original) research article will usually be divided into several labeled sections. The screenshot above is from the video "What is Original (Primary) Research in Criminology?". You can jump to the 3:10 timestamp to watch the "Sections of an original research article" segment of the video.

  • Abstract
  • Introduction (which usually includes a literature review)
  • Method (often called Methodology or Methods) -- always found in an empirical research article
  • Findings or Results
  • Discussion
  • Conclusions
  • References

The names of the parts may vary, but a primary research article will always include a methodology section explaining how the research was conducted (i.e. what type of empirical method was used). Most secondary journal articles do not include a methods section.

Practice Question 2 

Click on the link to each of the three items listed below. Each link opens in a new window. Look at all three items before voting.

To vote, click on the radio button for your choice, and click Submit. Please only vote once.

Which of these is a primary (empirical) research article?

Article 1: Toward a comprehensive model of antisocial development: A dynamic systems approach: 7 votes (11.86%)
Article 2: The psychology of criminal conduct: A consideration of strengths, weaknesses and future directions: 1 votes (1.69%)
Article 3: Dine and dash: An exploratory application of three criminological theories: 49 votes (83.05%)
All of them: 1 votes (1.69%)
Not sure: 1 votes (1.69%)
Total Votes: 59

PsycINFO

Ideas:

  • Try limiting your search to articles which include this Subject Term: THEORIES
  • Include the name of a theorist in your search, e.g. PATTERSON
  • Include the name of a theory or keywords that describe a theory in your search, e.g. COERCION

See Searching PsycINFO - Tips on the KPU Library's Psychology research guide.

Search techniques with examples

Technique

What it does

Example

Synonyms

Search for words or phrases that have a same or similar meaning

TIP: Type syn ____ into Google to generate synonyms (e.g. syn adolescent)

youth, teenager, adolescent

Spelling variations

Search for different spellings of a word

defence, defense

Truncation

Search for different endings of a word stem using the asterisk symbol

TIP: Check your database; it might use a different truncation symbol

crim* will search for
crime, crimes, criminology, and so on

Phrase searching

Search for all terms in the exact order specified within quotation marks

“racial profiling”

Boolean operators

AND will narrow a search by returning items only containing both terms

youth AND crime

OR will broaden a search by returning items with one or both terms. Use this to combine synonyms. Remember that OR = MORE results.

youth OR adolescent

NOT will narrow a search by returning items with the first term but not the second term

defence NOT hockey

PsycINFO tags articles based on the research methodology used. You can use these tags to filter your search results.

You can choose the Methodology filter either from the main Advanced Search screen or from the Refine options menu in your search results. 

Option 1: Finding PsycINFO methodology filter from the Advanced Search screen

screenshot of PsycINFO advanced search screen showing Methodology filter near bottom

Option 2: Finding PsycINFO methodology filter from the Search Results screen

screenshot of PsycINFO methodology filter in left menu of search results screen

VIDEO: Using the Methodology Limiter in PsycINFO (4:33)

Quick tutorial on how to filter your PsycINFO search results based on a type of research methodology, whether broad (e.g. empirical or qualitative) or very specific (e.g. focus groups or literature review). Link to definitions of methodology codes used in PsycInfo.

APA citation

3 APA citations for journals articles: 1) standard, 2) no DOI but freely-available online, 3) no DOI and not freely-available online

Text version of incorrect and corrected citations:

Incorrect

David, J.-D., & Mitchell, M. (2021). Contacts with the Police and the Over-Representation of Indigenous Peoples in The Canadian Criminal Justice System. Canadian Journal of Criminology & Criminal Justice63(2), 23–45. https://doi-org.ezproxy.kpu.ca:2443/10.3138/cjccj.2020-0004

Correct

 

David, J.-D., & Mitchell, M. (2021). Contacts with the police and the over-representation of Indigenous peoples in the Canadian criminal justice system. Canadian Journal of Criminology & Criminal Justice63(2), 23–45. https://doi.org/10.3138/cjccj.2020-0004

Citing your sources properly shows that you have done your research and consulted appropriate sources for your topic. It also acknowledges that all research builds on work that has come before. You are giving credit to sources that have influenced or informed your work. If you do not do this, you are essentially stealing another person's ideas, which is plagiarism.

Whenever you use another person's ideas (even if you put this into your own words), you must give them credit. You do this by CITING the source you used in two places:

  1. First, you give a brief in-text citation right in (or after) the sentence where you mention the idea or words.
  2. Then, you provide a detailed reference at the end of your document so that whoever reads it will be able to locate the exact source you used. 
    • note: the exact formatting of a reference will depend on the type of information source you are citing, but every reference should tell the reader WHO created the work, WHEN it was created, WHAT the work is called, and WHERE it can be found. 

Most library research databases include a tool that will automatically create formatted references. However, these often have mistakes and you MUST proofread them

Here are links to other tools that you can also use to create a rough citation:

Wiesner, M., Yoerger, K., & Capaldi, D. M. (2018). Patterns and correlates of offender versatility and specialization across a 23-year span for at-risk young men. Victims & Offenders13(1), 28–47. https://doi.org/10.1080/15564886.2016.1250691

Screenshot in library assignment

You will need to take a screenshot of your final search strategy and paste it into the library assignment. Use whatever screen capture tool you prefer. PC computers usually have a built-in Snipping Tool; see instructions below for the Snipping Tool. If you take a photo of your computer, make sure that the text in the image is clear enough to read easily.

If you can't take a screenshot, please see the alternative listed on the library assignment.

The screenshot should show:

  • the search keywords you used
  • the search commands you used (e.g. AND, OR) and how you used them to combine your search keywords
  • Any other search techniques and filters you used (e.g. the asterisk shortcut, the methodology filter)

Sample screenshot

Note: you do NOT have to circle this information on your screenshot. I have used the red boxes in the sample below to highlight what I'm looking for.

screenshot of PsycINFO search results

How to use the Snipping Tool on PC's to take a screenshot