Skip to Main Content

Fine Arts

Evaluating Sources

Purpose

The following are a series of questions to ask yourself whenever you encounter a source, whether online, through social media, recommended by a friend, or in a library database.

  • What is my purpose in looking for this information?
  • What is the purpose of this source?
  • How did I find this source?
  • How was this source created, recommended, disseminated?
  • How did I come to know about this source's existence?
  • Who is the intended audience?
  • Do I know what this thing is (can I summarize it and its intentions easily)?

Authority

Assessing authority can be tricky, but we often do it pretty hastily and without thinking. The following questions are designed to help you slow down and reflect on the authorship and authority of the sources you encounter.

  • Who is the author?
  • Is the source easy to investigate? How transparent is its claims, links, sources?
  • What are the creator's education, credentials, occupation, affiliations, other publications? How are these qualifications relevant to the information presented?
  • Is the resource peer reviewed or edited? If so, by whom?
  • Does the creator know what they're talking about?
  • Is the site stable? Has it been there for a while and does it look like it's going to stay?

Scope

Finally, we often assess the scope, currency, and coverage of sources without thinking, but they can tell us a lot about a source, and whether they are appropriate to our research.

  • Is the topic covered comprehensively or selectively?
  • Is coverage regional, national, or international?
  • Is coverage recent or historical?
  • Is coverage up-to-date?

Whether an image has been altered, and where it has traveled on the web

Recognizing photomontage or modified photos

Tracing Memes

Memes are images, videos, text, usually ironic or satirical, that becomes viral.  These two tools help you track the creation and diffusion of the most well known viral memes. 

Analyzing Video